To view the Master Plan for Open Spaces in the Golan - Public Participation Conference 19.12.11 file click here

Master Plan for Open Spaces in the Golan

Public Participation Conference 19.12.11

General

Within the framework of the Master Plan for Open Spaces in the Golan, a public participation conference was held for the residents of the Golan Regional Council. The conference was held at Ohalo College in Katzrin on December 19, 2011, between 18:00-21:30. Approximately 70 people from all settlements of the Golan Regional Council participated in the conference.

The conference included three parts:

Part A – On open spaces in the country in general and in regional councils in particular:
  • Open spaces in Israel – current situation and future challenges: Yoav Sagi, Head of the DESHE Institute, Society for the Protection of Nature in Israel
  • Planning open spaces in regional councils: Miki Lifshitz, CEO of the "Eretz Ahavti" Association, Center of Regional Councils
Part B – Master Plan for Open Spaces in the Golan

Initial deliverables: Arch. Ilan Eisen, Planning Team Leader.

All maps and materials prepared within the framework of the Master Plan for Open Spaces are available for comments and feedback on the Regional Council's website.

Workshops – Conference participants split into three working groups, in separate discussion rooms:

  1. Tourism, infrastructure, and open spaces – moderated by Aviad Sar-Shalom.
  2. Agriculture, grazing, and open spaces – moderated by Dr. Liron Amdur.
  3. Open spaces management – moderated by Arch. Ilan Eisen.
Plenary - Summary

About 25 residents participated in each group. A representative from each group summarized the main points.

Below are the central topics raised during the group discussions in the workshop session:

Tourism, Infrastructure, and Open Spaces Group

The issues discussed in the group were the development of tourism and alternative energies, against the backdrop of the existing master plan for tourism in the Golan, the master plan for alternative energies in the Golan currently under preparation, and the open spaces sensitivity map prepared as part of the Master Plan for Open Spaces.

Points raised by participants:

  • A participant requested to ensure that an extra-high-voltage power line, carrying the electricity produced from the proposed wind farms in the Golan to the Hula Valley, be buried underground, and that landscape sensitivity considerations be factored into the planning of energy projects.
  • Another participant asked to promote and reduce existing bureaucratic barriers to placing solar panels on residential rooftops, and to fully utilize this energy source before resorting to the use of open spaces.
  • It was proposed to examine whether wind energy could also be added to the southeastern Golan in the master plan for alternative energies. In addition, it was noted that the economic potential of large solar energy farms is very high, and therefore saw merit in associations between several settlements to develop such projects, at the expense of field-crop land. If the primary environmental issue is the power line, it was proposed to route the power line through Katzrin.
  • A participant asked to promote the installation of solar panels on roofs of various farm buildings in parallel with the establishment of solar farms in open spaces. It was also noted that there is no justification for the severe landscape damage resulting from adding a high-voltage line due to wind turbines in the Golan Heights. The participant requested that plans require attaching new power lines to existing infrastructure.
  • Another participant asked to examine whether the benefit of electricity produced from wind and sun justifies the severe landscape damage that such projects create. The Golan is a national tourism area, and therefore landscape damage must be kept to a minimum. Tourism revenue will justify refraining from developing energy projects.
  • A participant asked to re-examine the ecological value and the necessity of nature reserves in the Golan Heights. Historically, after the Six-Day War, the Chief of Staff at the time determined the location of nature reserves in order to establish facts on the ground and determine firing zones and military corridors. Today, a large portion of these areas is not utilized by the military and is closed to the general public. There is room to re-examine these areas and their content, and to allow tourism activity within them.
  • A participant stated that for the purpose of developing tourism in the Golan, hiking trails and wading pools should be cultivated, like in the springs area near Ma'ale Yonatan.
  • A female participant asked to rethink the issue of domestic tourism, mass tourism, whose development creates litter, noise, and traffic congestion on roads, making life difficult in the settlements, especially during summer months. She proposed that planning allow tourism development at specific points, with consideration for permanent Golan residents and their needs.
  • Another female participant expressed an opinion supportive of tourism, saying that the Golan Trail embodies appropriate development. She suggested developing walking paths for experienced hikers and families, and regulating dedicated areas for jeep tours and barbecues.
  • Another participant suggested that the plan focus on ecology. He said that alternative energy is the need of the hour, a fundamental issue in the state's long-term vision. At the same time, the planning of the electricity transmission line should avoid landscape damage as much as possible.
  • A female participant noted that she chose to live in the Golan Heights because of the proximity to nature and scenery, and therefore requested avoiding development in pristine natural landscape as much as possible, trying to adhere development to existing construction, and creating places of calm and quiet amidst the tourism hustle and bustle.
  • A participant proposed branding the Golan Heights not only in the context of "wild landscape" but also in the area of local agriculture, agri-tourism, and agricultural production. The Golan should offer agricultural produce at affordable prices, renew agricultural settlements, and develop projects reconstructing historic agriculture as a tourist attraction.
  • Participants said that one should not interfere in the farmer's choices regarding crop types, as long as it is not possible to guarantee the economic profitability of the farm.

Agriculture, Grazing, and Open Spaces Group

The group focused on the issues:

  1. The impact of agricultural cultivation on open spaces.
  2. The plan for expanding agricultural farmsteads in the Golan.
  3. The interface between cultivated lands and grazing lands.

Points raised by participants:

  • It was proposed to separate the approach to intensive agriculture (greenhouses, chicken coops, etc.) from extensive agriculture, with intensive agriculture needing to be conducted near the settlement.
  • The cattle ranchers' representative said that the plan for expanding farmsteads is welcome, and it is clear that this will be done at the expense of pasture. The plan must be carried out in cooperation with grazing practitioners. This is the first time that cattle ranchers are sitting in one forum with farmers, and this is commendable. Farmers do not see pasture land as agriculture, and this is reflected, among other things, in dumping pruning waste into pasture areas. The plan needs to regulate mutual understanding between farmers and ranchers.
  • The Agricultural Committee representative said that the committee represents all agricultural sectors, including grazing, and sometimes conflicting interests exist between the various sectors. There is representation for grazing within the Agricultural Committee. The Agricultural Committee is a statutory committee elected by the Council plenary. The committee is not elected by the public. Dialogue takes place in the Agricultural Committee with the Grazing Authority and the ranchers. The intention is to carry out the expansion of farmsteads without harming any rancher in a way that causes them to lose their livelihood. The committee is in dialogue with the settlements to coordinate the expansion of farmsteads. The first part of the work was to obtain approvals such as that of the Minister of Agriculture; the next stage is implementation of the plan. The goal is absorbing hundreds of new families in the Golan.
  • The Agricultural Committee is trying to create order in allocating agricultural land within the framework of the farmstead expansion plan. For this purpose, a regional headquarters was established whose members include various bodies, including the Council Head, the Ministry of Agriculture, Mei Golan, and others. Each settlement is requested to prepare a long-term 5-year plan. There is dialogue with the grazing sector and with the Nature and Parks Authority. It is anticipated that within two to three months there will be decision-making tools such as settlement plans, water plans, and more. It must be understood that increasing agricultural land by 31,000 dunams is equivalent to the scale of 10 new settlements. Land under temporary contract will primarily serve for expanding farmsteads. A settlement will be eligible to receive land only according to population intake. Although there are marginal encroachments by farmers or unregulated lands, these do not constitute the bulk of the land.
  • An orchard farmer said that the primary limiting factor in identifying new agricultural land is economic viability. It is difficult to determine the most suitable location for orchards. If damage is caused to a specific rancher, they must receive compensation for the damage caused to them - whether through reallocation of the area or through compensation in another way. In their view, separating uses such as tourism, agriculture, and grazing is essential. There is room for small projects in areas that are not within parcel allocations, for ornamental and tourism purposes and for combining tourism and agriculture, with community involvement. Projects can include a small park or an olive grove.
  • A participant who is a Golan resident and a Ministry of Agriculture orchard extension officer noted that the current trend in the Golan is the reduction of field crop areas in favor of orchards. Most of the new areas should go to orchards, and therefore it must be taken into account that all new agricultural areas will be fenced. Considerations for locating areas should be based on soil surveys for agriculture, water supply, and distance from the settlement.
  • One of the orchard farmers said that assuming income is preserved, he has no problem accepting environmental guidelines and restrictions on spraying, for example, against compensation payments that cover the economic damage incurred. Farmers have goodwill regarding nature conservation, but economic balance is needed.
  • He also noted that orchards cannot be grown without a fence. Farmers are exposed to damage from jackals, wild boars, foxes, mongooses, and more.
  • The interface between built-up areas and agricultural lands needs to be examined. For example - the community expansion of Moshav Ramot was carried out at the expense of an orchard, a situation that creates problems due to the use of spraying in the orchard in close proximity to residences.
  • A dairy farmer noted that about 10% of the milk in Israel is produced in the Golan. The Golan is a good area for raising dairy cows and this field can develop further. For this reason, care must be taken that not all agricultural lands go to orchards, but also to field crops for cow feed; it should be remembered that a large part of the cost of cow feed is associated with transportation expenses. He noted that dairy farmers also suffer from the problem of calf predation.
  • A Ministry of Agriculture representative said that he has been accompanying the farmstead expansion process for a long time. The plan was presented to the Programs Committee, and the areas that each settlement is supposed to receive were marked. It should be noted that about 25% of the areas in the plan are firing zones. Currently, there is disorder due to additional requests from settlements to expand areas. According to the legal situation, lands can be taken from ranchers without compensation because these are temporary lands. In my opinion, a framework is needed to create order in granting lands to settlements: who is first, who is last, how many dunams, whether to grant everything at once or in stages, and whether a distinction should be made between veteran settlements and new settlements. The locations appearing on the map presented today total 46,000 dunams, of which only 31,000 dunams are required for all settlements to meet the new established farmstead standard.
  • A sheep farmer said that there are people who received agricultural land but are not farmers, leasing the land to people outside the Golan. This is an illogical situation. There should be a situation where if it is not used, the land reverts to grazing land. There is a situation where settlements have lands with uprooted orchards. A rancher could use such land, but is not allowed to, even though the land sits empty for years. A question that must be raised is the question of mined areas: what happens to these areas, do they transfer to grazing or to agriculture? Ranchers currently work hand in hand with the IDF. An arrangement like the one with the IDF is needed with the Nature and Parks Authority as well. Nature reserves can also be utilized under certain restrictions for grazing.
  • A turkey farmer asked to address the issue from a macro perspective. Adding 800-900 new farmsteads means a significant increase in built-up area at the expense of open space, taking into account the required agricultural structures. This comes at the expense of open spaces near the settlement and increases the urban element within the Golan Heights.
  • An orchard farmer said that orchards "become tired" and it is possible that in 20 years we will not want to use them. It could be that combinations between uses will need to be made on a time basis rather than a spatial basis. In this way, an abandoned orchard would become grazing land, and later could also become field crops like wheat, for example.

Open Spaces Management Group

The group focused on the issue of how open spaces in the Golan should be managed, in which areas residents can take responsibility for managing open spaces, and in which forums.

Points raised by participants:

  • One of the ranchers said that cattle ranchers "fall between the chairs" in terms of administrative treatment; they are not considered farmers (using lands of nature reserves and KKL-JNF forests), and the system views grazing as the lowest priority. There are problems with conduct on the ground by residents and tourists, a lack of tools and rules for handling hazards, and the absence of a supervisory body for what happens in the field. The rancher proposed establishing a supervisory body funded by fines and fees, which would, among other things, enforce laws regarding lighting bonfires and camping.
  • A participant asked how the plan serves the 3 million tourists who visit the Golan Heights. He noted that the Bteicha is a special area in which it is necessary to define where to hike and where to camp. He noted that tourism in the Golan is important for recognizing the Golan Heights as part of Israel.
  • Another participant said that a priority map based on ecological data should be generated as the basis for preparing the plan. He expects to see a visibility map, fears what will happen "the day after" the plan's preparation, and therefore suggests establishing a mechanism aware of all stakeholders and familiar with processes such as invasive species and fires.
  • Another participant said that regional management should be carried out through the Regional Council and not through KKL-JNF or the Nature and Parks Authority. The Council is the right body because it conducts processes in participation with residents.
  • A female participant said that expansion neighborhoods in settlements often harm the landscape, except for special cases where planning was conducted with landscape thinking. She pointed to a need to develop promenades to places that lack accessibility.
  • One of the participants noted that he was part of the team that conducted the ecological analysis of the Golan carried out by the Nature and Parks Authority in 2004. He suggested establishing a single organization for managing open spaces in the Golan, including Katzrin and Druze villages, so there will be an address for managing open spaces just as education or sanitation is handled.
  • Another participant requested external supervision over the Regional Council's development plans, in participation with residents.
  • A female participant requested that the plan preserve ecological corridors along roads, prevent further road development, and arrange wildlife passages under roads. She requested that KKL-JNF engage in establishing tourism projects such as observation points.
  • A participant suggested that implementation of the plan be through the education system, reaching children and thereby reaching parents (as was done regarding wildflowers).
  • A participant suggested that each settlement develop scenic spots in cooperation with institutions, thereby adding tourist focal points in the Golan.
  • A female participant requested that the landmines issue be addressed.
  • A participant requested addressing the construction of chicken coops and fences, and accessibility to open spaces for the general public.